Home > News
Update: Gradient Problems with 3D: It's Not Just Us!
Florent Alzieu
August 12, 2010 11:11 AM
August 12, 2010 11:11 AM
Earlier this week, we published a story about the problems we had noticed with the posterization of gradients in 3D movies at the cinema. They sometimes look dreadful and end up very blocky in the darkest areas of the screen. We wanted to know if anybody else had noticed the same problem.
Reader TapTap did some research and found the following the instructions from 3D rental company rentme3d:
"If the movie is being triple flashed as Disney often requires [see our article 'Where we're at with 3D' for more details], a second problem, colour banding or posterizaton, can occur. This will be evident in large mid-tone areas that slowly transition from one shade of gray or colour to another. Instead of being continuous, the transition will be in steps or bands."
To understand this explanation, you need to understand how DLP projectors work. To change the intensity of a particular colour across the screen and produce, for example, a purple gradient, the micro mirrors have to combine a mixture of red and blue. Moving along the gradient, the intensities of each component vary. Unfortunately, because 3D glasses alternate eyes so fast, they split up the gradient into smaller blocks. Here's how it can happen and produce the rainbow effect with some projectors:
The photo taken at 1/200 s show that a very fast shot and split up the colours in a single frame.
> Buyer's Guides: Our Pick of The Best Products
Reader TapTap did some research and found the following the instructions from 3D rental company rentme3d:
"If the movie is being triple flashed as Disney often requires [see our article 'Where we're at with 3D' for more details], a second problem, colour banding or posterizaton, can occur. This will be evident in large mid-tone areas that slowly transition from one shade of gray or colour to another. Instead of being continuous, the transition will be in steps or bands."
Here's the graphic we used to illustrate the problem in our story on Monday:

3D glasses and DLP projectors at fault
So we're not going crazy—other people have noticed the same problem. The instructions go on to explain why this happens."This occurs because, while the lenses of the glasses go to the opaque state very rapidly, the transition to the transparent state occurs slowly enough that it takes a significant portion of the frame interval. Normally this would just result in a small decrease in brightness, but, because of the way a DLP projector modulates light, there can also be a reduction of colour depth."
To understand this explanation, you need to understand how DLP projectors work. To change the intensity of a particular colour across the screen and produce, for example, a purple gradient, the micro mirrors have to combine a mixture of red and blue. Moving along the gradient, the intensities of each component vary. Unfortunately, because 3D glasses alternate eyes so fast, they split up the gradient into smaller blocks. Here's how it can happen and produce the rainbow effect with some projectors:

The photo taken at 1/200 s show that a very fast shot and split up the colours in a single frame.
Solution
Rentme3D suggests two separate solutions: adjusting the time in between each frame as well as the dark time, but recognizes that this approach has its limits. If you go too far in one direction or the other, the picture can end up unstable or suffer from ghosting.
> Buyer's Guides: Our Pick of The Best Products
Previous story / Next story
-
13/08After Starcraft II, Duke Nukem Forever Keeps Gamers Hanging On
-
13/08Dell vs Apple for Back to School 2010
-
12/08Review: Sony Ericsson Vivaz Pro, plus an update on the Vivaz
-
Current story -Update: Gradient Problems with 3D: It's Not Just Us!
-
12/08HTC Desire HD, Google Phone XL
-
12/08Sony Bravia 40EX710 and 32EX710 Coming Soon!
-
12/08iPod Dock Reviews: Altec Lansing MIX and Harman Kardon Go+Play
-
12/15/11Projector Review: Vivitek Qumi LED, DLP, 3D Ready
-
12/13/11Desire S, Desire HD, Incredible S Get Android 2.3.5 and Sense 3.0
-
12/8/11Nintendo 3DS Fimware Update Adds 3D Filming
-
11/28/11Update: Iiyama ProLite E2473HDS: Same 24'' Monitor—But Better
-
11/10/11Adobe Gives Up On Mobile Flash
-
10/24/11Changes Afoot on DigitalVersus
-
10/14/11Seagate GoFlex Cinema, 1 TB Media Centre Under £100
-
10/8/113DS Video For Super Mario 3D Land
-
10/7/11Dark Souls: Prepare to Die Over and Over Again!
-
10/3/11Full HD 3D Projector: Epson EH-TW5900

News
Buyer's Guide: The Best Monitors
