logo_print logo_print_pub
Home > News

Readers Write: it's a RAID!

Vincent Lheur
May 31, 2010 2:17 PM
One of our readers recently e-mailed us with this question:

I saw that you recently tested the Verbatim Combo eSATA USB 2.0 and it got me thinking.

I'm looking to store large volumes of data in RAID 1 via e-SATA. I've thought of two ways of doing this and I wondered which one you thought would be best.

1. Buy two 2 TB external hard drives (I'd probably choose the Verbatim one mentioned above) and copy the contents of one to the other.

2. Buy an external enclosure with room for two 2 TB hard drives (I was thinking about the MAXINPOWER BEMIP35A7R) and set it up a RAID 1 configuration.

Which solution would keep my data safest? For example, in the second option, as the two disks have the same power source, could both disks be damaged if there's a problem with the enclosure?

Plus, I know it's not exactly a common product, but I'm having trouble finding tests or reviews of two-disk external enclosures.


F.C.

WD Caviar Green 1 TB
The second solution seems to be the most appropriate for your needs, as you won't have to spend ages copying the contents of one disk onto the other by hand. Plus, even if both disks in the second setup will effectively be running on the same power source, a breakdown wouldn't be catastrophic as you'd always be able to install them in a new enclosure to access the data stored on them.

It's true that you won't find many tests of this kind of enclosure out there as there's so little customer demand. To be honest though, there really won't be any huge differences between the models available, as with eSATA connections it's the disks themselves that determine the final performances. RAID 1 management will only slightly impact the performances, if at all. In the end, we'd always advise you to prioritise security over performance, and you can do this by choosing a 'green' type hard drive. Most of the big manufacturers now have a line of 'green' hard drives, which consume less power, are quieter and won't heat up as much as some other types of drive. Take a look at the WD Caviar Green 1 TB, for example.

> Product Survey: External Hard Drives

> Product Survey: Internal Hard Drives


> Buyer's Guides: Our Pick of The Best Products

Previous story / Next story

Our RSS News Feeds : 

Back to top