logo_print logo_print_pub
Archive: Multifunction Printers up to August 2009 >

HP Photosmart C6380

Vincent Alzieu
Test date: February 5, 2009
Scanner and copier

Historically, the HP scanner is not the best and this model holds true to the rule. Compared to those of Canon, it produces images with accentuated contours and contrasts that are a bit too strong. For the "amateur", it is fine. But not use at all for a pro. You need to make too many changes to get back to your original.

Moreover, the scanner is quite slow. The initial preview takes 17 seconds, 13 seconds for a scan of a 300 dpi 4x6" photo. Other cheaper models work twic as fast.

For copies however, it's much better. The black and white takes 14 seconds and the colour 22 seconds.


HP targets the individual consumer. This product is however more suited to professionals and SMEs. Indeed, you won't find this printer (ethernet, Wi-Fi, separate cartrides) in many hypermarkets. Especially as it has a choice of standard and XL cartridges, with ink economy in mind. Note, there is a separate "black photo" cartridge. Good point: the photos are more accurate than on HP printers that aren't equipped with this ink. Bad point: it will gradually get empty (very slowly), even if you only do office printing (see the final table at the bottom of the page).

Office printing: fast and high quality

Going up in the range with HP means you can finally achieve better speeds than the 4480 and 4580. You go from 5.3 ppm in colour to 10.6 ppm on this 6380! In black and white, there is less of a gain but still an appreciable one: around 12 ppm on our test document instead of 7 ppm on the others. And draft mode (excellent quality) goes up to 26 ppm. Do leave it on the default parameters as, although the blacks will be less deep, it's more economical.
The 6380, then, betters the Canon MP630 and its 8.5 ppm in colour and 10.4 ppm black and white.
Ok so it's fast but is this to the detriment of quality? In fact, no. Quality is more than satisfactory. Text and graphs are sharp. The text is a deep black and the characters precise. The tinted areas on the graphs are nice and even and the characters are clear.



Photo printing: rapid and as it should be


Photo printing is also fast: 45 seconds to get a 4x6" print, 1 minute 30 for an A4 format: more than ok. However, although photo quality is a bit better (more accurate) than on HP printers that don't come with the black photo cartridge, we are still some way off "photo quality" on Canon printers (or even HP) with the full photo cartridge (with a light cyan and magenta). If you look at the image closely, you'll still see ink drops. Nevertheless, this quality is more than good enough for your album.

Cartridges

Two different sets of cartridges are available. Standard and the more expensive XL, also much longer-lasting.

Cartridge
ISO lifespan

364 (black)
250
364 (cyan)   300
364 (magenta)
300
364 (yellow)
300
364 (black photo)
1500

With standard cartridges you'll already get a fairly decent yield. If you're not a big consumer, these will be enough. You'll have to change them more often but there'll be less risk that one dries out and blocks your machine. Because HP is following Canon's lead on its separate cartridges: the print heads are no longer on the cartridge itself (in contrast to their single unit cartridges) but in the printer. This necessitates more frequent cleaning so as not to risk blockages.
If you do a lot of printing, best to straight for the XL versions:

XL cartridges

Cartridge   ISO lifespan

364 (black)
800
364 (cyan)
750
364 (magenta)
750
364 (yellow)
750
364 (black photo)
4500

With XL economy is much better than average but still twice what you get with laser printers.

Pluses

-

Separate standard or XL cartridges, the XL are more economical

-

High speeds for an ink jet

-

Ethernet and Wi-Fi

-

Excellent office printing quality, very good draft mode

-

Fairly nice photos, fast

Minuses

-

Drops visible on the photos

4
What you have here is an excellent network printer, wireless, fast, good quality and economic, perfectly able to multi-task, even if the fussiest users will note the ink drops that are a little too visible on photos.

Our RSS News Feeds :