Review: Brother HL-4570CDW

Our score: 4/5
Latest Related Content
March 2, 2011 10:45 AM
14 want this Me too!
PRICE HISTORY  
E-MAIL ME  
E-mail me when the price drops below:
£
REPORT PRICING ISSUE:  
STORES avail Price £ P&P
Amazon 241.19 + 0.00 See offer  
Printerbase 244.80 + 0.00 See offer  
Shoplet 395.94 + 0.00 See offer  
Published: March 1, 2011 11:00 PM
By Marine Goy / Morgane Alzieu
Translated by: Jack Sims
The Brother HL-4570CDW laser printer is a single function colour laser designed for the pro world. It promises high quality prints at low cost.

Hardware

Aesthetically, this printer resembles a big cube! Described as being ideal for a busy office, it offers networked printing, wi-fi and double-sided. Whatever your religion (Mac, Windows, Linux), you'll find the necessary drivers available. Compatibility with PCL6 (Printer Command Language) enables file compression. The 128 MB memory should be enough for a work group of up to twenty people or so. A single function printer, it can't do copies, scan or fax.


                                                      The control panel

The four separate cartridges come in three formats: standard, large and very large.


Accessing the cartridges is easy and practical


Speeds: rapid and constant!

Although it takes a while to wake up and this means it loses a rating star (see inset), once up and running it offers rapid printing. The tech spec claims 28 pages per minute (ppm) and with our test documents we measured it at 30 ppm across the three modes (colour, draft, black & white). Double-sided speeds will be half this (15 ppm).



Quality

On our colour graph, the print lines are slightly visible in single tone areas and, although the graph is perfectly legible, fussy users will want a bit more precision (characters). If you push the default mode up from 600 dpi to 2400 dpi, single tone areas become much smoother (less lined) and characters look sharper and more precise, making them more legible.
In black and white, graph prints aren't as good. There's a slight banding effect (white vertical bands) though it isn't pronounced enough to compromise the legibility of the graph. Once again, if you're fussy you'll fault the slight lack of sharpness in characters. Again, this disappears when you print at 2400 dpi.


Laser printers aren't designed for photo prints. Out of curiosity, we ran the HL-4570CDW through its paces but, as expected, the results weren't great. Print lines are much too visible to give decent results.



Energy consumption & Noise levels
a record low on standby

Let's start with the outstanding score of 0.6W on standby. This would even be a low score on an inkjet. On lasers, it's a first! This goes up to 459 watts when running, not bad for a laser. Overall, it's very economical and were we scoring it for energy consumption alone, it would have merited a 5-star rating. Noise levels of 57 dB penalise it however. It's not noisy, but not not quiet either.
 



Cost per page


Among the three toner formats, the very high capacity cartridges come out less expensive in the long run. We did the sums and the standard capacity will cost you around double the next size up and, at 7.7 pence per page, the largest capacity cartridges cost around a third of the standards. This is better than the cost per page of the Brother MFC-9320CW (14.1 pence). The black ink is particularly competitively priced: 1.1 pence is excellent. The best cost per page is given by black & white laser printers. To cut your costs right down, turn on the black and white default.

ISO lifespan for text
High capacity cartridges

Toner Price
ISO lifespan
Cost per page
TN-328BK (black) £64.57 6000 1.1 pence
TN-328C (cyan) £130.57 6000 2.2 pence
TN-325M (magenta) £130.57 6000 2.2 pence
TN-328Y (yellow) £130.57 6000 2.2 pence

Colour drum unit
Price
ISO lifespan
Cost per page
 DR-320CL  £112.35  25000  0.45 pence

 

Transfer belt
Price
ISO lifespan
Cost per page
 BU-300CL  £73.32 50000 0.15 pence

 

 

4/5 Brother HL-4570CDW DigitalVersus 2011-03-02 00:00:00

Pros

  • Wi-fi, ethernet and double-sided
  • Rapid speeds in both black & white and colour
  • At 0.6W energy consumption on standby is exceptionally low
  • Cartridges in 3 formats (including very high capacity)
  • Simple to use / low cost per page (1.1 pence black & white) with very high capacity cartridges

Cons

  • No copier, fax, scanner
  • Slow to start-up
  • High cost per page with standard cartridges
  • Not the quietest machine

Conclusion

A good compromise for those looking for a colour laser printer that's easy to share in a work group. It gives good speeds and quality prints. Ease-of-use is a real bonus and, as a result, you'll be willing to ignore its imposing aspect. Cost per page is moderate (in particular in black & white) with very high capacity cartridges. The colour standard ones are much more expensive however!

OUR SCORE 4/5
ADVERTISING