Product Face-Offs
Home > News
Mac OS X Beats Vista In MacBook Pro Battery Life Tests
Florent Alzieu
October 30, 2008 6:15 pm
October 30, 2008 6:15 pm
The results of our battery life tests on the MacBook Pro under Mac Os X and Windows Vista are in and they give a classic example of how to handle--and how not to handle--power management.
We tested the same laptop on both operating systems using conditions that were as similar as we could make them.
On both platforms, we set brightness to 100 cd/m², turned off Bluetooth and WiFi and played a DivX movie on repeat until the battery was so empty the MBP went into standby.
In Mac OS X, we chose the power profile with the best energy consumption, which, for instance, deactivates the graphics card when it is not needed.
Things were a little more complicated under Vista. This is partly because there are no official Nvidia drivers for the 9400M chipset used by the MBP, meaning you can't configure it as a regular component from Control Panel. We were forced to overide the system and try the 177.81 drivers, which, should, in theory, work with this hardware.
Here's the results:
We tested the same laptop on both operating systems using conditions that were as similar as we could make them.
On both platforms, we set brightness to 100 cd/m², turned off Bluetooth and WiFi and played a DivX movie on repeat until the battery was so empty the MBP went into standby.
In Mac OS X, we chose the power profile with the best energy consumption, which, for instance, deactivates the graphics card when it is not needed.
Things were a little more complicated under Vista. This is partly because there are no official Nvidia drivers for the 9400M chipset used by the MBP, meaning you can't configure it as a regular component from Control Panel. We were forced to overide the system and try the 177.81 drivers, which, should, in theory, work with this hardware.
Here's the results:
As you can see, our efforts with Vista were in vain and the battery life results were very weak: it barely scrapes past an hour while under Mac OS X you can keep on going for over three.
Of course, this test is far from entirely representative--we don't imagine many people will be buying a MacBook Pro to watch movies in Vista, for instance, when it's something you can do perfectly easily from inside Mac OS X, or any other computer for instance.
We'd also expect far better results if Apple made it possible to install graphics drivers using Boot Camp.
Of course, this test is far from entirely representative--we don't imagine many people will be buying a MacBook Pro to watch movies in Vista, for instance, when it's something you can do perfectly easily from inside Mac OS X, or any other computer for instance.
We'd also expect far better results if Apple made it possible to install graphics drivers using Boot Camp.
Previous story / Next story :
- 03/11Samsung Reveals 40'' OLED Prototype
- 31/10New Product Survey: Internal Hard Drives
- 30/10New Test: Mio C728 GPS
- Current story - Mac OS X Beats Vista In MacBook Pro Battery Life Tests
- 30/10Dedicated SDHC Cards for Netbooks from PNY
- 29/10New Tests: Four 22'' LCDs
- 28/10New Test: Pentax K-m / K2000
Check out all of our High Tech offers: TV, Computing, Camera, Gaming, Telephony, Blu-Ray DVD on Pixmania
- 17/11Laptop Tests: HP Envy 15 and Asus G60J
- 18/09Test: new iPods from Apple -- just out but we've already tested them!
- 12/08New Tests: Cowon S9, Samsung Q2 and a fresh look at the iPod Touch
- 31/05Quo Computer: a hackintosh shop in California
- 05/05New Test: Apple iMac 24''
- 12/2008New Tests: Five Laptops
- 11/2008New Tests: Five-Star Headphones from Jays!
- 19/11Test: Blackberry Curve 8520, a smartphone for anybody
- 19/11New Test: Samsung SP-A600B, an inexpensive Full HD DLP projector
- 18/11Camcorder Test: Canon HF S11
- 18/11New Tests: 19'' Monitors from HP, Samsung and Iiyama
