Face-Off: Pick the Products You Want to Compare

Nikon Coolpix S5100 Canon Ixus 115 HS
Photo
Nikon Coolpix S5100
Overview - Full review
Canon Ixus 115 HS
Overview - Full review
Price
Overall Scene
Nikon Coolpix S5100
Canon Ixus 115 HS
Score
2/5
4/5
User Score
4/5 (1)
Specifications
Specifications
SensorCCD 12 Mpx, 1/2.3", 42 Mpx/cm
Lens 5x 28 -140 mm f/2.7 -6.6
StabilisationOptical
ViewfinderN.A.
Screen6.7 cm, TN, 230000 dots, 4:3,Not touch-sensitive
Sensitivity (ISO range)100 - 3200 ISO
Video mode1280 x 720 pixels,30 fps, Mono
Internal memory32MB
External memory
Connections
Power sourceN.A. N.A. / EN-EL10
Waterproofno, N.A.
Shock resistantno, N.A.
Dimensions/Weight59 x 97 x 22 mm / 132 g
Specifications
SensorBSI CMOS 12 Mpx, 1/2.3", 42 Mpx/cm
Lens 4x 28 -112 mm f/2.8 -5.9
StabilisationOptical
ViewfinderN.A.
Screen7.6 cm, not TN, 230000 dots, 4:3,Not touch-sensitive
Sensitivity (ISO range)100 - 3200 ISO
Video mode1920 x 1080 pixels,24 fps, Mono
Internal memoryN.A.
External memory
Connections
Power sourceN.A. N.A. / NB-4L
Waterproofno, N.A.
Shock resistantno, N.A.
Dimensions/Weight57 x 93 x 20 mm / 139 g
Conclusion
The Nikon Coolpix S5100 lives up to expectations: it's a basic camera with inconsistent build quality that's counting on its cute, colourful looks and its low price to help you forget about its only just acceptable picture quality (that's really quite bad in telephoto mode!).
The Canon Ixus 115 HS is a nice surprise, boasting good internal electronics, a pleasant build and a sleek design, all for a price at which basic CCD sensors, harsh plastics and TN screens are still the order of the day. Canon just needs to improve the video mode and lens quality at wide-angle settings.
Pros

+

Stylish front face

+

Simple controls and menus

+

Fast, responsive

+

Separate video record button

+

High-quality build and materials used

+

Good picture quality up to 800 ISO

+

Good picture quality at telephoto settings

+

1080p HD video mode with sharp picture quality

+

Easy to use

Cons

-

Low-definition screen with poor viewing angles

-

Image quality not consistent accross the frame in wide-angle mode

-

Blurring in telephoto mode

-

Video mode with no optical zoom and mono sound

-

Lens could be sharper at wide-angle settings

-

No stereo sound or optical zoom in video mode

-

Could be more responsive

-

Low-def screen

-

Flat buttons set flush into the casing aren't always practical