logo_print logo_print_pub
Computer Mice Reviews >

Apple Magic Trackpad

MARCHANDS
 
 
Amazon marketplace  42.69 
Amazon.co.uk  48.20 
Viking  57.60 
Comet  61.00 
   
   
Compare prices
Caractéristiques
SensorN.A.
Wired? / Docking Station?no / no
Battery2 x AA
Maximum ResolutionN.C. v69
Reporting FrequencyN.A.
Vincent Alzieu
Translator: Jack Sims
Test date: August 28, 2010
Installing the Magic Trackpad in Windows on a PC

Apple requires Mac users to have version 10.6.4 of their OS minimum for the Magic Trackpad, while PC drivers for Windows work from XP upwards (on download from Apple's site!).

Two versions of the drivers are available depending on your PC OS: 32 or 64 bits.

The problem is that they have been designed for a Mac with Bootcamp, the software that allows you to move from one OS to another. This is a pre-requisite for these drivers, which have not been designed to run on a PC running Windows alone.

There is however a not completely official manual to help you install these drivers on a PC. Labnol.org details the operation perfectly. Once you've downloaded the file, decompressed it the first time with 7-zip, then again extracted the content of the file that has been created (BootCampUpdate32.msp).

Several répertoires then appear, one of which contains the file Binary.AppleWirelessTrackpad_Bin (use the Search feature in Windows). Add the .exe extension to this file (F2 key to modify its name, add .exe at the end). And voila! You can now install it (it takes just a few seconds).

Now, whether you're using it on Mac with Bootcamp or on PC, the result is the same. It would've been naïve to think that all the features you get with the Mac OS X would be present in Windows: you lose the three finger manipulations. With the official drivers, the Magic Pad in Windows therefore becomes a pad with a left click, a right click and two-finger multitouch. Already not bad...


Apple 59.00
Once again Apple has surprised us - without even trying this device we all know, just by looking at it, what it will be able to do. It's immediately obvious how to use it.


The only questions we may have are rather with respect to spending out £59 on a peripheral that no one was using up until now. It'll need to find its niche.

The Pad range: the anti-PCs

The Apple strategy is impressive in terms of its implacability. While the PC world has been involved in in-fighting for years to develop "raw performance", with processing being sectioned off for GPU treatment and CPUs with ever-more cores, Apple is doing the exact opposite on its Pad range. They have gone back to the basics of today's digital experience.


95% of users know virtually nothing about the spec of their computer and they, frankly, don't give a damn! Knowing this is no use to them in their everyday digital experience.

The Pad range responds to the simplest daily requirements very well (internet, email, social networks, photos, video, gaming). This Magic Pad is part of the same logic. It has been designed to replace the mouse. This giant Pad is perfect for messaging, for sorting through photos, rotating them and zooming in on more detail. It's all you need to start and control a film - especially from your couch, as it has a range of 10 metres, though you do need to configure it on your Mac to be able to click just by tapping it - or check on a friend's online status.

Like the iPad however, the Trackpad won't be enough for certain other "expert" tasks. For most video games for example. Or for retouching a photo in detail, or editing a video. For all these usages, nothing yet measures up to a really precise mouse, such as the G500.

In practice


It's no surprise (we're talking Apple quality here) to see that the finish and the trackpad surface are really excellent. It is also robust and won't suffer from knocks or falls. Nor do the batteries dislodge easily: two batteries are used to power it (Apple is advertising its rechargeable batteries on the Magic Trackpad page...) and have been intelligently placed in the base used to raise the pad.

We do however differ from most of the opinion published so far in our analysis of its responsiveness. We have two Trackpads and both show latency on usage. There's a slight difference (a few tenths of a millisecond which you can even see on the video here, filmed at 30 fps or one image every 33 ms) between movements on the pad and what appears on screen - probably due to the Bluetooth link. Nothing too serious then, but certainly not perfect. Fussy users will of course notice it and the delay could even become annoying.

You can see the latency on the video.

This apart however, simply its size makes it a great improvement on laptop trackpads. Your hand falls naturally on it, without having to bend at the wrist. One thing to note: although the whole area is clickable, the higher up you go the harder it is to click. You therefore quickly get used to clicking in the lower part of the pad.


Upside down: note the right and left click connectors at the bottom in the corners.

You get used to using it right away: after 15 minutes you'll know your way around it perfectly. In addition to the left and right clicks (the whole area is clickable), several features (some of which are reserved for Macs) are built-in to the Pad.

A lateral movement with three fingers allows you to move between the various applications that are open. A vertical movement will displace a desktop application. With two fingers (PC and Mac here), you can rotate objects, zoom and browse.

This Apple video shows you the available options and resulting actions from the various gestures:

The next logical link in the chain

Apple has progressively flattened its mice to finally arrive at the design of this only slightly-raised Pad. The large touch area is nice to look at and practical but the next logical step is towards touch screens.

Lets imagine for a second tomorrow's world with a range of iMacs and Macbooks all with touch screens. Would we still use this peripheral?
Apple 59.00
We're therefore considering the Magic Pad with some circumspection. Paranoid mode ON. What if we were being asked to spend out £59 just to get us used to touch manipulations and make us want more, so that it's easier to sell us computers with touch screens when they come out? How long a life will the Magic Pad therefore have? Should we go for it, if in six months, a year, or two years down the road (even this doesn't seem realistic) Apple revolutionises its range and announces a "touch revolution"?

Though perhaps, as some of our readers are saying, the ideal would be a pad combined with touch screen.
Pluses

-

Easy to use, though nobody had used one previously

-

Superb finish

-

Works perfectly on your Mac and well on PC

-

Nice replacement for the mouse in many cases

-

You can set it to your liking (on Mac)

Minuses

-

A new outlay for a product with questionable lifespan

-

Need to cheat a bit to install it on PC

-

Very slight latency between movement on pad and the screen

-

The upper part of the pad is hard to click

-

Doesn't work well on dual-screen. Best to use it on a single screen.

The Pad is useful, pretty and practical, but for how long? It replaces the mouse nicely for many usages, but as soon as touch screens come on stream, you'll be putting it away in a drawer never to be seen again. Your mouse will still be useful.
MARCHANDS
 
 
Amazon marketplace  42.69 
Amazon.co.uk  48.20 
Viking  57.60 
Comet  61.00 
   
   
Compare prices

Our RSS News Feeds : 

Back to top