Articles >
Home Cinema Speaker Reviews
Nothing compares to a 5.1 system to go alongside your Blu-Ray player and TV or video projector. Whether with an amplifier and player or speakers on their own, a few hundred or several thousand euros, you'll find systems for all tastes and budgets.
Tristan François
Published: January 29, 2010
Published: January 29, 2010

How do we test speakers?

No great surprise here, our test procedure for speakers is largely based on the tests for computer headphones and speakers.
Much of the test therefore consists in listening to a playlist of pieces and songs we know off pat, and noting the differences between the different products. Here, because these systems are primarily for home cinema use, we've also added some Blu Ray extracts.
We're going to develop the test procedure further. The human ear, exceptional as it is, is not infallible. This is why, soon, readings taken on each system that passes through our hands will be added to the test, so you can visualise the differences between products and make your own choice.
Much of the test therefore consists in listening to a playlist of pieces and songs we know off pat, and noting the differences between the different products. Here, because these systems are primarily for home cinema use, we've also added some Blu Ray extracts.
We're going to develop the test procedure further. The human ear, exceptional as it is, is not infallible. This is why, soon, readings taken on each system that passes through our hands will be added to the test, so you can visualise the differences between products and make your own choice.
All-in-one or separates?
There are two types of system: all-in-one package systems or separates. The advatage of the all-in-ones is that they're generally cheaper, take up less space and are often better designed to suit your decor than large floorstanders. Separate speaker packages give modularity however and the option to develop your solution almost endlessly. Indeed, if you go for a separate player, amplifier and speakers, you can replace them one at a time and spread your spending.
Think about the set-up!
Going for separates brings modularity, sure, but also a number of problems. While linking your Blu-Ray up to your amplifier won't pose any compatability problems, linking the amp up to the speaker system is another matter altogether. You must, for example, at all costs avoid choosing an amp that isn't powerful enough for your speakers - they wont last anywhere near as long. And don't take tech specs as gospel! Measurements aren't especially standardised and it isn't always easy to make the right choice.
Is a subwoofer really necessary?
This isn't a trivial question, quite the opposite. There are two very different possibilities. Systems with small satellite speakers or "bookshelf" speakers don't reproduce the bass frequencies properly. Forget what it says in the spec, it may well claim a frequency of from "20 Hz - 20 kHz", the difference in reproducible volume between a sound at 50 Hz and another at 1kHz is such that the bottom of the spectrum will be missing in the majority of cases. Here then, the subwoofer is indispensable, especially for home cinema usage. If, however your system includes floorstanding speakers, you may well find you don't need a subwoofer. With the membrane area you get with these, they're much more effective with bass sounds. Make sure you get information on product capacity before you buy. In fact, a film enthusiast will often require more bass than a music lover. Everything depends on your requirements.
Listen before buying!
Don't trust the numbers and don't buy anything blind. Have pity on your ears and before you go and spend several hundred pounds on a 5.1 system, go and listen to it. Go into your local Home Cinema/Hi-Fi shop and have a listen to a selection of systems. Even if you're going to buy on the net, this way you'll avoid any nasty surprises - personal taste also comes into things and you need to find out what suits your ears!





Product Face-Offs











