FranceUnited KingdomUSADeutschlandItalia
Scanner Reviews >
Canon CanoScan LiDE 700F
Specifications
Type CIS
Resolution 4800 dpi
Scans negatives? yes
Inferface USB 2.0
Self-powered? yes
See all specifications
Document feeder? no
Network? no
Compatible with PC/Mac/Linux yes / yes / no
Dimensions/Weight 292 x 409 x 44 mm / 2.1 kg
Hide specifications
Nilofar Hadjanadjiboudine
Updated: August 21, 2009 - Test date: August 19, 2009
Canon LiDE 700F vs. Pixma MP260

The Canon Pixma MP260 is our favourite multifunction inkjet printer of 2008/09. It's 'multifunction' because it includes a scanner, and the whole thing--printer, scanner and copier--costs the same as the LiDE 700F.

For basic scanning for use at home, the MP260 definitely has the advantage. Images are a little easier on the eye, with more contrast and more sharpness. It's worth being careful, though, as it does have less accurate colours. To try and achieve a more attractive result, the scanner in the MP260 alters all of the colours just a little and produces discrepancies that are worse than those on the 700F. It's nothing terrible, though, and at the end of the day, both scanners are equal on this front. This verdict poses a few problems for the 700F, though, given that it has far fewer features than its all-in-one rival but costs the same.

The 700F does have a few tricks up its sleeve though:
- size: if you don't need a printer, why use more space than is needed for this ultra-flat scanner? - negative scanning: it doesn't claim to meet the needs of professional photographers who have a whole archive to digitise, but it does allow you to scan in old negatives to view on your computer or print out again. - automatic removal of dust and scratching - shortcut buttons to allow you to scan a page and immediately e-mail it.
The Canon LiDe700F is a Contact Image Sensor (CIS) scanner that's a lot flatter than average, a whole centimetre thinner than the Epson Perfection V30.

Its major strong point: it can scan both printed photos and your original negatives for a low price.

An entry-level option, the 700F is powered by the USB connection with your computer.  Photos can be scanned at up to 4800 dpi, while negatives reach 9600 dpi.  A series of buttons allow you to scan directly to an e-mail or a PDF ...

The scanner uses very little power while it's working: just 3 W.  In standby mode, it requires almost no power--nothing power than a few mW.

One practical feature is that the 700F can be operated in a lot of different positions.  It can lie flat on your desk, of course, but also vertically to save space.


Speed

A preview scan of a document only takes 10 seconds, which is fast.  Scanning a 4 x 6'' colour photo at 300 dpi is also fast at just over 5 seconds.  However, when you increase the resolution, the hardware begins to slow down.  For instance, scanning a stamp at 2400 dpi takes almost a minute and a half, an operation that Epson's scanners can do it just 42 seconds.

The scanner's other main feature is that it can digitise negatives.  This is easy to do and very clearly explained in the manual.  Scanning a film at 1200 dpi takes just under 31 seconds, which is fast.  However, when it comes to scanning at 9600 dpi, the scanner's maximum resolution, you can expect to wait almost 12 minutes 45 seconds, which is far too long.

Quality

Original Scanner


What to look out for:
Orange tones that are hard to reproduce, details in the hair, skin tones.

96 dpi

Overall, the results are pleasing.  But the colours aren't quite right: it's too red/orange.  Some dark areas are too light also.


What to look out for:
Details in the hair, skin tones.

300 dpi


Some details are missing.  The face is bright, but doesn't have much contrast.



What to look out for:
You should be able to see eyelashes and eyebrows.


600 dpi

There is a lot of detail missing and the whole thing is quite blurry
.

The scanner includes a sharpness mode, which is activated by default, but it's a little too powerful.  It makes the image too sharp by accentuating individual strokes too much.  The effect might be attractive to some people who find the result cleaner and sharper.

Without sharpness mode With sharpness mode
2400 dpi scan of a postage stamp

After our 'real photo' tests, we moved on to try our test cards.  They confirmed once and for all the discrepancies we had already found, which were most troubling for reds and caused greys to be too light.

On the top row is the image produced by the 700F; below are the ideal colours from the test card.



Quantitatively, the distinctions are as follows:
Looking at the different errors, it's clear that the colour problems are mainly found with yellows, reds, greys and blacks.  The average discrepancy is around 6.2%.  These results confirm what we had already been able to see: the problems with yellows and reds explain the reddy-orange tint to the test scans we made.  Similarly, the grey is visibly wrong on our colour test card, where the black is noticeably washed-out.

Original Scanner
Scan from a negative

When scanning films, the quality is reasonable, but once again, the colours are a little washed out and lack contrast.  The lack of a strong, deep black is noticeable.  Any photos you can scan from negatives will be benefit from a little retouching.  Nevertheless, the photo is entirely useable and can be printed with generally satisfactory.  It's difficult to expect more at this price!
Pluses

-

Bright, lively scans at low resolution

-

Negative scnning

-

Doesn't take up much room

-

Shortcut keys

-

Can be used vertically as well as horizontally

Minuses

-

Scans quite slowly at higher resolutions

-

Problems with yellow, red, grey and black

It's small, can even be used standing up and it can scan your negatives, not just your photos. There's a lot going for the LiDE 700F, even if it the colour problems we found mean that a little retouching will need to be done before you commit to paper.
 
Next page
 

Our RSS News Feeds : 

Add to Netvibes